The Weatherman
Comments: 6 - Date: October 31st, 2007 - Categories: Songs
The Weatherman
© Williams 2007
A pile of coins on the bedside table
I took the train, would have driven if I’d known
A pile of gold and brown in the window
I took the chance to walk where the autumn leaves had blown
These sheets have been disinfected
The ground outside has been laid bare
A ghost of cloud wonders if we meant it
And skeletons of memory vanish into sterilised air
And a storm is coming
And the train has pulled away
I’m left with an empty bed
And a fistful of promises to make
A pile of books on the bedside table
Spines are broken and the pages dry
There are words in here I could have spoken
And there are leaves I should throw into the winter sky
And a storm is coming
And the train has pulled away
I’m left with an empty bed
And a fistful of promises to make
On a windy Sunday
When the sun is sinking low
When the sea is dancing
Now I find that I don’t want to let you go
These rooms have been scrubbed and steam cleaned
And all the windows polished til they shine
There is no dirt underneath my fingernails
The weatherman says it will be sunny and fine
Download: The Weatherman (mp3)
Background
I’d actually like to know what you get from this song. So, let’s play a game. Stop reading this until you’ve downloaded and listened to it, then tell me in the comments what you understand from it. Think of it like book group for a song – you don’t need to know what the author intended to read and discuss it.
Go on!
And then come back and read what I have to say about it.
Which is this: it’s about loss. Der! I wrote it in 2005, when I was staying in London with Midshipman Louise and his family, and I was working through my feelings of being on the other side of the world from Australia, and of packing up my life and the flat I’d lived in for three years – goodbye, home. But it’s also about the loss of loved ones, about the instant of death and about missing it, or not being there, about hospitals, about regretting not saying what should have been said. So it’s about loss and about grief, it’s about people and place, about identity and space, and about memory.
Now, the “Three Blind Mice” bit? Random! When I was recording I realised that this fitted in to the song. I needed some more live instrumentation, and my voice happened to be right there, so I just experimented. I like the way the nursery rhyme adds another level of association to the song: I think it brings in a sense of (past) time and memory (childhood) to set against the present. Or am I just being a bit too wanky?
It’s kind of interesting to see, though, that in last week’s TOTALLY COOL song, I was all about the seasons and the weather, and time and loss and I HAVEN’T CHANGED! Whoops. I hope, though, that this is slightly less crap. Oh, man, I hope so. Please tell me it is!
Recording
Damn, this recording has given me so much grief. SO MUCH. I originally wrote it on piano, and it was a very, very simple arrangement. Honestly, it’s possible that it sounds better that way. But I don’t have a piano, so I have to make do with the GarageBand software, which is difficult to get a nice sound out of (lots of playing with EQ, let me tell you!). Because I’m playing on the computer keyboard it’s never quite on the beat, and when I change it to be in time it’s too perfect. So I added guitar, just quietly, to give the mix some warmth and humanity and not sound quite as much like karaoke. I also used drums and beats, because . . . um, BECAUSE I COULD! Because if I’m going to use the metronome and keep to a beat I might as well make the most of it. I’ve got the, uh, “Percussion Combo 09.20” drum loop all the way through, elaborated in places with “Effected Dum Kit” beat loop. Hilarious. Oh yeah, I also have some “Orchestral Strings” doing bass for me.
I’ve tried a lot of stuff with this mix, including doing a master track EQ and effects. I’ve had to do a master EQ (and compression) because goddamn it’s difficult to re-train my mixing style for myself. It is so hard to mix a deep voice and try to differentiate it from the low instruments. This one sounds a bit muddy, I think, but it’s much better than it was yesterday, and I can not look at it again or I will scream. Part of the problem is that it sounds completely different through the headphones, the good speakers and the speakers of my laptop. The usual scenario: My headphones are great, and everything is lovely and clear and well mixed. In the good speakers, the lead vocals are seven times too loud, the bass is completely blown out, and there’s fuck-all treble. In the crap speakers, there’s no bass to speak of, so the backing vocals and guitar seem to be taking over. Wah! This time I tried mainly to make it sound OK on the good speakers, though I did some tweaking using the headphones.
If any of you have any suggestions about the mix, let me know – i.e. would you prefer the vocals louder? Less bass? Less mid? More bass on the guitar? More panning? I know there are at least two of you with more mixing experience than me! Speak!
Likings and Not-Likings
I put these together today, because a lot of them are flip-sides. For instance, I like that the lead vocal doesn’t stand out as much as usual because it works more as one instrument among many. On the other hand, I really like a clear, separate vocal line in music.
I like that I can have drums, and I quite like having them in there, but I’m afraid they sound a bit tacky and fake, and are a bit repetitive.
I like the kind of fun-ness of having the nursery rhyme in there, but I wonder if it adds or detracts from the overall song?
Conclusion
Basically, it comes down to this: I like that I’ve tried out a whole heap of things, but I’m not sure about the end product. Also, I need a decent microphone, because I simply cannot convert shit recording into great mix. As they say, crap in, crap out.
As usual, if you’d like to share with people, please link to this post, rather than to the download. Thank you!